Dining at Olivia’s Cafe

This hidden gem features a menu full of Island-inspired dishes. After having some of Olivia’s hearty home cooking, you’ll understand why it is a favorite of many a guest!

Menus

WebGrabber: Could not find the HTML element: #Appetizer.group, #Entree.group, #Dessert.group, #Kids.group

Appetizers

Crab Cake

Pan-seared and served with Jalapeño Aïoli Sauce, Grilled Pineapple Salsa, and Chayote Slaw
$13.00

Conch Chowder - Olivia's Own Recipe

Manhattan-style served with Oyster Crackers (Available after 11am for Brunch)
$9.25

Homemade Soup of the Day

Made fresh daily, ask your Server for today's special
$8.00

Tomato-Mozzarella Salad

Cherry Tomatoes, Fresh Mozzarella, and Orange Segments with Mixed Greens, Ciabatta Crostini, and Balsamic Glaze
$11.00

Conch Fritters

Served with Key Lime-Mustard and Roasted Red Pepper Rémoulade
$12.00

Olivia's House Salad

Mixed Greens with Seasonal Accompaniments and House Dressing
$9.00

Caesar Salad

Chopped Romaine Lettuce tossed with Parmesan, House-made Croutons, and Caesar Dressing
$9.00

Caesar Salad with Chicken

Chopped Romaine Lettuce tossed with Parmesan, House-made Croutons, and Caesar Dressing
$15.00

Caesar Salad with Shrimp or Steak

Chopped Romaine Lettuce tossed with Parmesan, House-made Croutons, and Caesar Dressing
$16.00

Chickpea and Quinoa Croquettes

Chickpea and Quinoa Fritters with Mango-Ají Amarillo Mojo, Pineapple-Rum Chutney, and Arugula Salad
$11.25

Olivia's Sandwiches

Duval Street Burger

Topped with Grilled Shrimp, Pepper Jack Cheese, Avocado, and Pico de Gallo on our Pineapple-Coconut Roll
$19.00

Miss Vickie’s Veggie Burger

Veggie Burger topped with Cheddar served on an Onion Roll
$15.00

Fish BLT Sandwich

Blackened Fish served with Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Applewood-smoked Bacon with Chipotle-Mayonnaise
$18.00

Shrimp Po' Boy Sandwich

Fried Shrimp served with Lettuce, Tomato Salsa, and Roasted Pepper Rémoulade Sauce on a Hoagie Roll
$16.00

Conch Flats Club Sandwich

Roasted Turkey, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, and Mayonnaise on Multigrain Toast
$15.00

Beef and Blue

Thinly Sliced Prime Rib, Blue Cheese, Fried Onion, Arugula, Horseradish Cream, and Tomato Jam
$17.00

Entrées

Steak with Pommes Frites

Grilled Steak served with Demi-glace, Homemade Steak Fries Seasoned with Truffle Oil and Parmesan with an Arugula Salad
$25.00

Southernmost Buttermilk Chicken

Mashed Potatoes, Southern Gravy, Biscuit, and Seasonal Vegetables
$21.00

Pork Carnitas

Marinated with Caribbean flavor and served over Lime Rice, Black Beans, Chayote Salad, and Herb Chimichurri
$17.00

Cayo Hueso Shrimp Pasta

Sautéed Shrimp, Zucchini, Yellow Squash, Grape Tomato, and Spinach tossed with Penne Pasta and Pesto Cream Sauce
$24.00

Mallory Square Cobb Salad

Romaine Lettuce with layers of Chilled Shrimp, Crab Salad, Bacon, Egg, Blue Cheese, Tomato, and Avocado with a Key Lime-Mustard Vinaigrette
$19.00

Allergy-friendly Offerings

Allergy-Friendly menus available upon request

Desserts

Mascarpone Cheesecake

with Seasonal Fruit Topping
$8.50

Tropical Chocolate Tart

Avocado-Chocolate Ganache with a Mango-Lime Sorbet garnished with a Toasted Coconut Crumble
$8.00

Key Lime Tart

with Mango and Raspberry Sauce
$7.00

Mile Marker Zero (No Sugar Added)

Tropical Panna Cotta
$8.50

Banana Bread Pudding Sundae

Served Warm with Bananas Foster topping and Vanilla Bean Ice Cream
$7.00

Kids' Appetizers (à la carte)

Garden Salad

$3.00

Grapes

$3.00

Celery and Carrot Sticks

$3.00

Sliced Apples

$3.00
Kids' menu items for children ages 9 and younger.
Look for the Disney Check icon on printed menus to find options that meet Disney's nutrition guidelines.

Kids' Create-Your-Own Entrées (choose one)

Spaghetti Squash and Turkey Meatballs

Served with choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small Dasani® Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice
$10.00

Grilled Chicken

Served with choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small Dasani® Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice
$10.00

Seasonal Grilled Fish

Served with Pineapple Salsa choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small Dasani® Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice
$12.00

Buttermilk Fried Chicken Tender

Served with choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small Dasani® Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice
$11.00

Chickpea Slider

Served with choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small Dasani® Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice
$10.00

Mickey Pasta

Served with Marinara Sauce and choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small Dasani® Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice
$10.00
Kids' menu items for children ages 9 and younger.
Look for the Disney Check icon on printed menus to find options that meet Disney's nutrition guidelines.

Kids' Create-Your-Own Selections (choose two)

Broccolini

Green Beans

Brown Rice

Fruit Cup

Mashed Potatoes and Gravy

No Sugar Added Sorbet with House-made Gummies

Yogurt Parfait

with Strawberries

Ice Cream Sundae

Kids' menu items for children ages 9 and younger.
Look for the Disney Check icon on printed menus to find options that meet Disney's nutrition guidelines.

Kid's Specialty Drink

Specialty Character Drink

Minute Maid® Light Lemonade served in a souvenir Character Cup with a glowing Character Clip-on Light
$8.00
Kids' menu items for children ages 9 and younger.
Look for the Disney Check icon on printed menus to find options that meet Disney's nutrition guidelines.

Appetizers

Crab Cake

Pan-seared and served with Jalapeño Aïoli Sauce, Grilled Pineapple Salsa, and Chayote Slaw
$13.00

Conch Chowder - Olivia's Own Recipe

Manhattan-style served with Oyster Crackers (Available after 11am for Brunch)
$9.25

Caesar Salad

Chopped Romaine Lettuce tossed with Parmesan, House-made Croutons, and Caesar Dressing
$9.00

Caesar Salad with Chicken

Chopped Romaine Lettuce tossed with Parmesan, House-made Croutons, and Caesar Dressing
$15.00

Conch Fritters

Served with Key Lime-Mustard and Roasted Red Pepper Rémoulade
$12.00

Homemade Soup of the Day

Made fresh daily, ask your Server for today's special
$8.00

Tomato-Mozzarella Salad

Cherry Tomatoes, Fresh Mozzarella, and Orange Segments with Mixed Greens, Ciabatta Crostini, and Balsamic Glaze
$11.00

Entrées

Grilled New York Strip

served with Parmesan-Roasted Fingerling Potatoes, Seasonal Vegetable, and Herb Chimichurri
$34.00

Tortuga Seafood Stew

Shrimp, Scallop, Mahi Mahi, and Mussels simmering in a Tomato Broth with Cannellini Bean, Chorizo, Fingerling Potatoes, and a Focaccia Crostini
$26.00

Southernmost Buttermilk Chicken

Mashed Potatoes, Southern Gravy, Biscuit, and Seasonal Vegetables
$21.00

Seven Mile Sea Scallops

Pan-seared Scallops over soft Polenta topped with an Edamame-Pancetta Succotash and Tomato Vinaigrette
$27.00

Plantation Key Pork Chop

Brined Bone-In Pork Chop glazed with an Apple-White Balsamic Gastrique served with Sweet Potatoes, Apples, Onions, Arugula, Cranberries, and Apple Vinaigrette garnished with Candied Nuts
$25.00

Slow-cooked Prime Rib

14-oz cut with Olivia’s Potatoes, Seasonal Vegetables, and Cabernet Demi-glace
$37.00

Fish of the Day (Market Price)

Cayo Hueso Shrimp Pasta

Sautéed Shrimp, Zucchini, Yellow Squash, Grape Tomato, and Spinach tossed with Penne Pasta and Pesto Cream Sauce
$24.00

Allergy-friendly Offerings

Allergy-Friendly menus available upon request

Desserts

Mascarpone Cheesecake

with Seasonal Fruit Topping
$8.50

Tropical Chocolate Tart

Avocado-Chocolate Ganache with a Mango-Lime Sorbet garnished with a Toasted Coconut Crumble
$8.00

Key Lime Tart

with Mango and Raspberry Sauce
$7.00

Mile Marker Zero (No Sugar Added)

Tropical Panna Cotta
$8.50

Banana Bread Pudding Sundae

Served Warm with Bananas Foster topping and Vanilla Bean Ice Cream
$7.00

Kids' Appetizers (à la carte)

Garden Salad

$3.00

Grapes

$3.00

Celery and Carrot Sticks

$3.00

Sliced Apples

$3.00
Kids' menu items for children ages 9 and younger.
Look for the Disney Check icon on printed menus to find options that meet Disney's nutrition guidelines.

Kids' Create-Your-Own Entrées (choose one)

Spaghetti Squash and Turkey Meatballs

Served with choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small Dasani® Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice
$10.00

Grilled Chicken

Served with choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small Dasani® Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice
$10.00

Seasonal Grilled Fish

Served with Pineapple Salsa choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small Dasani® Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice
$12.00

Buttermilk Fried Chicken Tender

Served with choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small Dasani® Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice
$11.00

Chickpea Slider

Served with choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small Dasani® Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice
$10.00

Mickey Pasta

Served with Marinara Sauce and choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small Dasani® Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice
$10.00
Kids' menu items for children ages 9 and younger.
Look for the Disney Check icon on printed menus to find options that meet Disney's nutrition guidelines.

Kids' Create-Your-Own Selections (choose two)

Broccolini

Green Beans

Brown Rice

Fruit Cup

Mashed Potatoes and Gravy

No Sugar Added Sorbet with House-made Gummies

Yogurt Parfait

with Strawberries

Ice Cream Sundae

Kids' menu items for children ages 9 and younger.
Look for the Disney Check icon on printed menus to find options that meet Disney's nutrition guidelines.

Kid's Specialty Drink

Specialty Character Drink

Minute Maid® Light Lemonade served in a souvenir Character Cup with a glowing Character Clip-on Light
$8.00
Kids' menu items for children ages 9 and younger.
Look for the Disney Check icon on printed menus to find options that meet Disney's nutrition guidelines.
Disney Quick Service Dining Plan

  • Breakfast – n/a
  • Lunch – n/a
  • Dinner – n/a

Disney Dining Plan

  • Breakfast – (1) entitlement per person
  • Lunch – (1) entitlement per person
  • Dinner – (1) entitlement per person

Disney Deluxe Dining Plan

  • Breakfast – (1) entitlement per person
  • Lunch – (1) entitlement per person
  • Dinner – (1) entitlement per person
Advanced Dining Reservations (ADRs) are strongly recommended and can be made up to 180 days prior to your visit. Menu items and pricing are subject to change.

Disney's Old Key West Resort

  • 1510 North Cove Road
    Lake Buena Vista, Florida 32830

Breakfast

  • 7:30a – 10:30a

Lunch

  • 11:30a – 4:55p

Dinner

  • 5:00p – 10:00p

* Restaurant hours subject to change and may vary.